Cracking in Harsh Environments Needs Stress and Corrosion, But Not at the Same Time

September 10, 2019

You are here

Electron microscopy of crack injection. Corrosion creates a nanoporous layer in the material (left) that propagates almost twice as far into the grain boundary as it does away from the boundary. The right image shows an injected crack.
Electron microscopy of crack injection. Corrosion creates a nanoporous layer in the material (left) that propagates almost twice as far into the grain boundary as it does away from the boundary. The right image shows an injected crack.
Image courtesy of Arizona State University

The Science

Alloys (metals combining two or more metallic elements) are typically stronger and less susceptible to cracking than pure metals. Yet when alloys are subjected to stress and a harsh chemical environment, the alloy can fail. The reason? Cracks caused by corrosion. The cracks are generally thought to propagate slowly by the simultaneous, parallel actions of stress and corrosion where the tip of the crack never proceeds beyond the corroded area. Now, researchers revealed that the cracking proceeds more quickly than they thought. That is, stress can inject a crack far into the un-corroded region.

The Impact

The team studied a form of corrosion called intergranular stress-corrosion cracking (IGSCC). Caused by environmental conditions, this type of corrosion causes cracks to propagate through alloys. It leads to the degradation of materials often used in bridges, airplanes, and power-generating stations. The research shows that the structure that forms where tiny grains of two metals meet in an alloy can lead to cracks in an area previously unaffected by corrosion. This insight is critical to designing new alloys that deter stress corrosion-induced failures and to better assessing the lifetime of existing alloys in service.

Summary

Scientists believed IGSCC requires the simultaneous presence of tensile stress and corrosion; however, the exact nature of this synergy has eluded experimental identification. The team examined the behavior of a laboratory model silver-gold alloy. The alloy mimics the corrosion behavior of important engineering alloys, such as stainless steels and nickel-based alloys used in nuclear power plants. Corrosion in these engineering alloys, as in the model silver-gold alloy, results in nanometer-sized holes within the corroded layer. A key parameter determining the occurrence of rapid IGSCC is the adhesion between the corroded layer and the un-corroded alloy. To study the alloy, the team used atomic-scale techniques, together with statistical characterizations. They determined that the apparent requirement for the simultaneous presence of stress and corrosion exists because of time-dependent morphology changes that affect adhesion. As long as adequate adhesion between the layers is maintained, a crack that starts with the corroded layer may penetrate into the un-corroded alloy. If the nanoporous corroded layer breaks away from the un-corroded alloy, the local stress drops and the crack only grows slowly. This means that there can be a significant mechanical component to stress-corrosion cracking that cannot be identified by any measurement of corrosion. It also means that the crack can progress even if the stress is applied after the corrosion stops. The result is that a corrosion measurement can underestimate the rate of stress-corrosion cracking by multiplicative factors of 10 or more. The research clearly shows that the roles of stress and corrosion can be decoupled, but there is synergy in these effects that leads to material failure. The results provide a path forward for obtaining a more complete understanding of IGSCC of alloys that are currently used. The new understanding also provides a foundation for designing new materials with improved properties for harsh energy and industrial environments.

Contact

Karl Sieradzki
Arizona State University
karl.sieradzki@asu.edu

Funding

This work was supported by the Department of Energy (DOE), Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences and Engineering Division. The atom probe tomography and focused ion beam were made available through the Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory, a DOE Office of Science user facility.

Publications

N. Badwe, X. Chen, D.K. Schreiber, M.J. Olszta, N.R. Overman, E.K. Karasz, A.Y. Tse, S.M. Bruemmer, and K. Sieradzki, “Decoupling the role of stress and corrosion in the intergranular cracking of noble-metal alloys.” Nature Materials 17, 887 (2018). [DOI: 10.1038/s41563-018-0162-x]

Related Links

Arizona State University press release: ASU research finds better predictors of metal structure failures