FIA-24-0045 - In the matter of Berger Montague

FOIA Appeal; Exemption 4; Granted

Office of Hearings and Appeals

September 9, 2024
minute read time

On August 20, 2024, the Office of Hearings and Appeals (OHA) granted a Freedom of Information (FOIA) appeal filed by Berger Montague (Appellant) from a determination letter issued by the Department of Energy's (DOE) Office Public Information (OPI). The Appellant submitted a FOIA request seeking information regarding a loan  (Loan) between Li-Cycle Holdings  Corporation  (Li-Cycle)  and  DOE  through  the  Loan  Program  Office's  (LPO) Advanced  Technology  Vehicles  Manufacturing  (ATVM)  program.  In  a  first  partial  response, OPI  produced  a  responsive  record  which  withheld  certain  information,  such  as  the  Loan's term  sheet  (Term  Sheet),  pursuant  to  Exemption  4.  After  reviewing  the  appeal,  OHA concluded that only information "obtained from" Li-Cycle could be properly withheld from the Term Sheet pursuant to Exemption 4. Accordingly, OHA granted the appeal and remanded to OPI for a determination as to which information in the Term Sheet was "obtained from" Li- Cycle. (OHA Case No. FIA-24-0045)