The Department of Energy's (DOE's) Wind Energy Technologies Office (WETO) works with electric grid operators, utilities, regulators, academia, and industry to create new strategies for incorporating increasing amounts of wind energy into the power system while maintaining economic and reliable operation of the grid.
Utilities have been increasingly deploying wind power to provide larger portions of electricity generation. However, many utilities also express concerns about wind power's possible impacts on electric power system operations, because wind's variability adds uncertainty beyond what is present due to variations in electricity demand (also called load). These concerns, if not adequately addressed, could limit the development potential of wind power in the United States.
As the nation moves toward an energy system with higher penetrations of wind energy, it is increasingly important for grid operators to understand how they can reliably integrate large quantities of wind energy into system operations; additionally, it is important to develop capabilities that enable these new wind power plants to provide much-needed Essential Reliability Services (e.g. frequency and voltage support) that can improve the reliability and resilience of the electric grid.
The office's goal in renewable systems integration is to remove barriers to wind energy grid integration, find innovative way to couple renewable energy technologies, and accelerate deployment to enable economic and reliable power grid operation with large shares of wind energy. This can be accomplished through integration studies, modeling, demonstrations, and assessments at both the transmission and distribution levels, coupled with working directly with utilities to help ensure adoption of best practices.
Current Research Project Highlights
Office researchers work with industry partners on projects aimed at better understanding integration issues and building confidence in the reliability of wind generation. This includes conducting wind integration studies; developing models needed for transmission system planners; understanding how wind energy can impact electricity markets; and assessing a variety of other technical impacts of integrating wind into the grid. To explore grid integration projects funded by the Wind Energy Technologies Office, see the summaries below or view our WETO R&D Projects Map and select Program Area: Grid Integration.
As part of the DOE’s launch of the Grid Modernization Initiative (GMI) in 2016, WETO systems integration activities were re-evaluated to align with the structure of the GMI. WETO supports projects in the GMI technical areas through the Grid Modernization Laboratory Consortium, which is a strategic partnership between DOE and the national laboratories to collaborate on grid modernization:
- Devices and Integrated Systems Testing
- Sensing and Measurements
- System Operations, Power Flow, and Control
- Design and Planning Tools
- Security and Resilience
- Institutional Support.
Device and Integrated Systems Testing
New distributed devices (e.g. inverters, distributed wind, rooftop PVs) and systems (e.g. advanced distribution management systems) will help deliver the flexibility required by the future grid for managing variable generation, engaging customers, and enhancing reliability and resiliency while keep electricity affordable.
This technical area develops devices and integrated systems, coordinates integration standards and test procedures, and evaluates the grid characteristics of both individual devices and integrated systems to provide grid-friendly energy services.
DOE’s National Renewable Energy Laboratory and Idaho National Laboratory are developing and testing coordinated active power control by wind generators, short-term energy storages, and large industrial motor drives. The coordinated control, which controls the power output, will be able to provide optimized ancillary services such as inertia control and frequency regulation to the grid. This will minimize loading impacts, thereby reducing operation and maintenance costs and subsequently the cost of wind energy.
Sensing and Measurements
Measuring and monitoring vital parameters throughout the electric power network are necessary to assess the health of the grid in real-time, predict its behavior, and respond to events effectively. Lack of visibility and accurate device- or facility-level information makes it difficult to operate the electricity system efficiently and has contributed to large-scale power disruptions and outages. Additionally, next-generation sensors will allow energy management systems to integrate buildings, electric vehicles, and distributed systems.
DOE’s Argonne National Laboratory and National Renewable Energy Laboratory are creating an open situational awareness and decision support platform, "WindView," which will provide grid operators with knowledge on the state and performance of their power system, with an emphasis on wind energy. WindView will use advanced visualization to display pertinent information, extracted through computational techniques from wind power forecasts for a high-wind penetration system.
System Operations, Power Flow, and Control
The existing grid control systems were developed over several decades using a set of 20th-century design characteristics: centralized dispatchable generation connected to transmission, relatively slow system dynamics that permitted manual control, no significant grid energy storage, passive loads, one-way flow of real power at the distribution level, operation for reliability, and generation-following load for balancing. Several of these design parameters have become outmoded by new technologies, changing economics, and shifting customer expectations. This area focuses on new control technologies to support new generation, load, and storage technologies.
DOE’s Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory is leading the collaboration with other national laboratories to create an integrated grid management framework that will be akin to having an autopilot system for the grid’s interconnected components—from central energy management systems (EMS) for bulk power, to distributed energy resources on distribution management systems (DMS), to local control systems for energy networks, including building-management systems (BMS).
NREL is developing an innovative, integrated, and transformative approach to mitigate the impact of wind ramping and reduce integration costs by designing flexible ramping products that can co-optimize energy, reserve, and ramping.
A dynamic line rating (DLR) system that accurately monitors real time environmental conditions will lead to improved line ampacity rating, better knowledge of operational/reliability issues, and potentially safer operations of the overall system. The project, led by Idaho National Laboratory, intends to refine, validate, and verify the prototype DLR tools, provide analysis and planning tools for capital investment maximization of existing and future transmission lines, and establish a path to promote the utilization of the proven system.
Design and Planning Tools
Sound long-term planning and design yield smart capital investment. Electric power grid modeling and simulation applications are fundamental to the successful design, planning, and secure operation of power systems with billions of dollars in capital investments and operations costs. However, existing planning and modeling tools have not kept pace with the complex technology, policy, economics, and outcomes demanded for the electric grid.
NREL and PNNL are convening industry and academic experts in power systems to evaluate the high-voltage, direct current and alternating current transmission seams between the U.S. interconnections and propose upgrades to existing facilities that reduce the cost of modernizing the nation's power system.
DOE’s NREL and Sandia National Laboratories are developing the ability to more accurately estimate the economic impact of renewables, storage, and other technologies through new production cost modeling capabilities that can address growing uncertainty and system complexity. The project is researching scalable methods for deterministic and stochastic probabilistic collocation methods, developing higher-resolution grid models, and applying uncertainty quantification and high performance computing. New capabilities will be deployed with system planners through workshops.
This study, led by NREL, is a collaboration between the United States, Canada, and Mexico is studying the impacts of renewable integration in North America. The goal is to help inform stakeholders to better understand the implication of integrating large amounts of renewable resources and to better understand the impact of cooperation between nations and between grid operators.
Security and Resilience
There are ever-increasing natural and man-made threats to the electric grid, including high-impact and low-frequency events, severe storms, fuel delivery failures, and more frequent physical and cyber threats. This technical area aims to meet physical and cybersecurity challenges, analyze asset criticality, assess ways to minimize risk, address supply chain risks (specifically for transformers), and provide situational awareness and incident support during energy-related emergencies.
Part of this project is developing a dynamic line rating system that will be operationalized in a partnering utilities control center. This system is being tested against potential cyber threats and hardened to avoid potential attacks in order to ensure reliable utilization of the system.
Technical assistance to key decision makers is important so that they can address the high-priority grid modernization challenges and needs identified by electric power industry stakeholders. It gives particular emphasis to working with state policymakers and regional planning organizations, with support for both analysis of issues and creation of information for stakeholders.
This project, led by NREL and Argonne National Laboratory, is one of the first to link together wholesale electricity market and generation expansion models with production cost simulation and reliability analysis. The goal is to create a multi-timescale market and reliability modeling framework to better understand the impacts of wind on the electric power system as it is operated today and in the transition to a modern, clean, and flexible power system in the future.
This project is bringing the tremendous research, data, methods, and results from wind integration work by national laboratories to utilities, international power system industry, and other stakeholders. It also aims to educate decision-makers on operational and market impacts of wind energy and dispel common misconceptions.
Past Research Project Highlights
Some highlights of past DOE-funded grid R&D include large-scale studies of future scenarios with high penetrations of variable renewable generation, such as a grid expansion and wind curtailment study (35% wind), Western Wind and Solar Integration Study (30% wind and 5% solar), Eastern Renewable Generation Integration Study (30% wind and solar), and National Offshore Wind Energy Grid Interconnection Study (54 GW offshore wind). Some DOE-funded grid operation R&D highlights include studying how wind technology can assist the power system through active power controls, and studying how wind can cool transmission lines thereby increasing transmission line capacity.
View past renewable systems integration project highlights here.
Grid Integration News
Grid Integration Featured Publications
The National Offshore Wind Energy Grid Interconnection Study (NOWEGIS) considers the availability and potential impacts of interconnecting large...Learn More
This report evaluates how wind power can support power system reliability, and do so economically. The study includes a number of different power...Learn More