Blog

Critical Materials Innovation Hub Reflects on 10 Years of Successes

The Critical Materials Innovation (CMI) Hub looks back at 10 years of support within the U.S. Department of Energy.

Advanced Materials & Manufacturing Technologies Office

October 1, 2024
minute read time

The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE’s) Critical Materials Strategy led to the establishment of a national resource for innovative technology development: the Critical Materials Innovation Hub (CMI Hub). Formerly known as the Critical Materials Institute, the CMI Hub has created a lasting innovation ecosystem operating under a shared mission since its inception in 2013.

Mission

The CMI Hub is a DOE Energy Innovation Hub led by Ames National Laboratory that seeks to accelerate innovative, scientific, and technological solutions to develop resilient and secure supply chains for rare earth metals and other materials critical to the success of clean energy technologies.

Impacts

Inspiring and empowering people is a key component of the Hub. 

More than 400 students and postdoctoral scholars have or are currently participating in the CMI Hub. 

Alumni have gone on to careers in government, industry, DOE national laboratories, and universities, as the leaders, technical experts, and skilled professionals needed to assure critical materials supply chains in the United States.

Of the R&D 100 Awards won in 2023, two projects included past members of the CMI Hub Leadership Academy, demonstrating that these emerging leaders continue to have strong research programs.  

50

U.S. Patents

202

Invention Disclosures

$80M+

Additional Government Awards

12

R&D 100 Awards

635

Peer-Reviewed Publications

50

Technologies Licensed

Case Study: From Lab Research to Licensed Technology

Two scientists in protective gear look at samples in several pots in a lab
Syed Islam and Ramesh Bhave, both at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, with purified critical materials recovered by membrane solvent extraction
Photo from Oak Ridge National Laboratory

CMI Hub researchers at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) developed membrane solvent extraction, an energy-efficient, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly process to recover rare earth metals. They generated aqueous solutions containing multiple metal ions by dissolving end-of-life products and scrap, which then passed through patented membrane modules that contain bundles of hollow fibers in which only certain metal ions can pass through. The technology won a 2020 Federal Laboratory Consortium Technology Transfer Award and has been licensed by CMI Hub partner Momentum Technologies for recovery of rare earth and battery critical materials. ORNL and Momentum Technologies received follow-on funding through the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law to commercialize the process.

An icon of a copyright symbol on a badge

Patent Analysis Highlights

An icon of a paper with magnifying glass over a corner

Publication Analysis HIghlights

An icon of a brain made up of dots and connecting lines

Citation Analysis Highlights

  • Out of CMI Hub-funded research patents:

    • 14 influenced more than 5 other patents. 
    • 68 patent families are cited by both private industry and academic institutions. 
    • Focus on lithium and rare earth elements fills a research gap.

    CMI Hub-funded research has earned patents that have influenced subsequent technological developments both within and beyond critical materials across a range of technologies, depicted in this tree.

    A tree of labels
  • CMI Hub has produced:

    • 16,200 publications 1794-2022
    • 475 peer-reviewed publications 2013-2022
    • 9.747 citations 2014-2023.

    CMI Hub's publications record demonstrate the evolution of research over time and reflect the Hub’s ability to adapt to dynamic market conditions. Nine out of 10 keywords with the highest growth were cited in CMI Hub publications after 2018, showing the Hub’s focus on pivoting to the most promising areas, including: 

    • Magnet
    • Recovery
    • Permanent magnet
    • Defect
    • Magnetic field
    • Microstructure
    • Cerium
    • Coercivity
    • Ga2O3 
    • Additive manufacturing. 

    For example, the CMI Hub started out by looking into phosphors of lighting, and pivoted to gallium and Indium supply research when LEDs became so cheap that the research in substitutions for rare earth elements wasn't as high as a need and the demand of gallium and In increased. 

    The top 10 sources that have published CMI Hub articles include:

     

    Journal

    Number

    1JOM19
    2Physical Review B17
    3Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials16
    4Resources, Conservation and Recycling14
    5ACS Sustainable Chemistry and Engineering12
    6Environmental Sciecne and Technology11
    7Minerals, Metals and Materials Series11
    8Inorganic Chemistry10
    9Journal of Applied Physics10
    10Journal of Materials Chemistry C10
  • CMI Hub publications:

    • Were cited 51% more than expected. 
    • Show widespread thought leadership and influence. 
    • Demonstrate the evolution of research over time and reflect the hub’s ability to adapt to dynamic market conditions.

Relevant News

Tags:
  • Critical Materials and Minerals
  • Circular Economy and Sustainable Manufacturing
  • Advanced Manufacturing Processes
  • Commercial Implementation
  • National Labs